November 14, 2026 – John Mulaney / Phoebe Bridgers (S52 E6)

Cold Opening – CIA Meeting

tech moguls are taught attractive-and-potentially-spying women aren’t into them

  • Very solid, refreshing way to address the recent AI-related scandals going on.
  • Nice seeing John front-and-center in the cold open for a change. He is fitting as if he is a cast member, which is something I always appreciate in his hosting stints.
  • JAJ’s look as Peter Thiel is killing me, as is the deep voice he is using.
  • Ben as Sam Altman is a solid choice, as I can see facial resemblance between them.
  • Jeremy’s Elon Musk impression has improved since it debuted last week.
  • Love the very dumb answers by these “genius” execs about what to do when a woman, way above their league, is suddenly interested in them. This is so different and fun from how formulaic and same-y many cold opens in this era have been, especially having multiple topics in one cold open. While this SNL era is a big improvement over the black hole of satire that was most of the late ’10s era’s political pieces. I appreciate this fun change.
  • A very good, smart cold open so far, especially in both lampooning these AI tech moguls and their behavior. This season so far has been tearing them apart almost, and, while that could feel indulgent on both the show and writers side, the writing behind these pieces has been solid thus far. Not just tearing these ghouls for sport but having a strong comedic throughlines as well.
  • I am getting so many laughs from the combo of John’s always-strong straight man work, the oversimplified PowerPoint presentation on what to do and not, and the cast as these moguls. Jeremy and JAJ are especially stealing this cold open. Jeremy seems to be having such a blast playing Elon in as unsettlingly a way as the real man comes off.
  • Nice Bowen Yang cameo. Seeing him in this surprisingly doesn’t feel as surprising as when former alums cameo. Perhaps that he feels like a part of the cold open’s ensemble instead of being front-and-center.
  • Bowen is his usual solid and likable self. Very good lines given to him, too.
  • A great cold open in general. One of the best in a long while. I really hope this solid, fresh cold open (which I am sure will go viral) is the way forward, as they really should be phasing Trump from these opens for both the primaries to come and JAJ to get to play other figures.

Rating: ****

Monologue

host does a stand-up about autism, baby boomers & RFK Jr.

  • John Mulaney is not only one of my personal favorite SNL writers and hosts of all-time, but one of my favorite comics period. I loved all of his prior SNL sets. So, needless to say, I am excited to cover this one.
  • Needless to say, feels nice reviewing a master at his craft, after sitting through whatever the hell Shane Gillis was going for in his own set a few episodes ago. Hey, I like Shane perhaps more than many in the fandom, but I cannot argue much there with the ones who tore him up.
  • Anyways, it sure it is easy of John to crack me up. his natural delivery is so damn funny and tickling, without much effort. One fan on Reddit affectionately described John as speaking with every word capitalized, and that is both a funny and dead-on description.
  • Loving John’s material about autism and his dad, especially his material on the classic Usual Suspects ending with their dad’s autistic behavior.
  • A solid “how come your faces are making water” line.
  • Very good baby boomer/Gen Z comparison part. As someone with an elderly parent, a lot of this is making me laugh even more than some who do not relate as much.
  • Love the segue to the material about RFK Jr. A good vocal impression from John, too.
  • John is killing me as he imitates RFK Jr. and his measles foray. John’s usual physicality is making this material even funnier.
  • Great joke about the Hudson River and condoms.
  • Another very strong, fun set from John Mulaney. In fact, my favorite set since way back to Dave Chappelle’s from season 50.

Rating: ****1/2

Plane Crash

plane crash reveals surgeries

  • It makes sense to have a sketch around the FAA (which I thought would be the cold open in fact), but do we need it to be a Seiday goofy names sketch? I will still give this an open mind, however.
  • Ashley is solid as usual, but by this point in the season, it feels that she is the one getting almost every single major female role, outside of last week’s episode, where the airtime between the women felt more balanced (though Veronika has been severely underused so far this season). Look, I think Ashley is a very talented, strong cast member, but I have no idea why the show often uses the other women in either dull straight man roles (which feels like almost all of Sarah’s role by this point) or just small roles. They are solid, talented. Give them more airtime as well. The male side seems far more balanced in use this season by comparison.
  • Back to the sketch, John is making the best out of the writing given to him. The horrifying visual of his head’s transplanted hair is unsettling, though.
  • This sketch seems to be about the FAA crisis more than the goofy name gag with John led me to believe.
  • Ben is also fun, though him and John are not exactly given much here besides the great makeup work.
  • The cast are making the most of this rather thin premise, as the reveals of them doing various plastic surgeries are getting less and less funny.
  • JAJ gave me the biggest laugh out of this whole sketch with his excellent delivery at the end.

Rating: **1/2

Sister: Elder Care System

your best medical assistant is your sister

  • Refreshing use of Tommy as John’s dad, especially give how I feel both of them could be siblings/relatives. Great makeup work on him.
  • Feels perfect to have a traditional fake ad in a John Mulaney episode after a while without one.
  • A fantastic reveal of the product advertised as simply having your sister take care of your elderly parent. I really relate to this, as I am taking care of my mom nowadays as she is getting really there in age.
  • Love the “features” of the advertised sister being nonchalantly that she is 1) your sister and 2) free. This just had me on the floor.
  • Mikey is very solid in his delivery as the doctor, though that feels like such a JAJ role to me. Another refreshing use of a cast member, however.
  • Jane is great as the main sister in this commercial, especially her awkward short conversation with her dad.
  • Tommy is great in this and surprisingly believable as an old dad.
  • Very funny brief back-and-forth between Ben and Jane.
  • Yet another fantastic fake ad from this era. They have been on a real roll with these since last season.

Rating: *****

Coworkers Drinks

Kathy (ASP) haunts coworkers at a bar

  • Oh, God. I knew this sketch would eventually be brought back, given what a big hit the first one was with many fans. But, it still feels like a waste of John to bring this sketch, which could be done with any other host.
  • Look, I feel I have underrated that first sketch now that’s been many months removed from it, even when I really do not see it as a classic, but it does not work as a recurring sketch. See, it all was built on the elements of surprise and escalation, which do not work in a repeat, as this is one that doesn’t even bother to change the straight men next to the host.
  • The more I see Sarah Sherman, who is spending these past few seasons sitting around tables, the sadder I feel. To think this cast member was meant early on to be a revolutionary hire to see her having the dullest tenure possible with barely, if ever, any comedic roles outside of a desk piece every five weeks, is beyond sad.
  • The catchphrase here is nowhere near as catchy as the first sketch. I am glad for the fans this character resonates with, and Ashley is often top-notch, but this sequel is not working for me.

Rating: **1/2 (and the first sketch, for now, will probably be rated at ***1/2, though that could definitely change if I fall really for it)

Gettin’ It Done

program host (JEC) faces identity crisis after kiss with brewmaster (host)

  • This feels so different and refreshing (boy, have I been overusing that word in this review) for your usual SNL pretape. I am looking forward to seeing where this goes.
  • Jeremy continues to have such a great season so far. Possibly the best of any cast member thus far.
  • John looks a lot like an actor or some celebrity in that beard and wig. I am struggling to think of whom, however.
  • The direction and cuts are absolutely dead-on recreation of these types of programs.
  • I am not sure what to make of that man-on-man kiss as it came out of nowhere. I am glad it was not played for cheap laughs, though.
  • Ah, Jeremy’s character having identity crisis now due to the aforementioned kiss. Great premise and is fitting to tackle in such a smart, thoughtful way. This is relatable to me as a queer person as well.
  • Jeremy is great in this short in general. John is also great in this role and how they are falling for each other. I also appreciate the melancholic tone underneath all the usual cheery lines in these programs.
  • Jeremy’s character having a gay awakening as the program keeps going on is great, especially loved the moment where we see his family as his iPhone’s background.
  • Some excellent lines during Jeremy’s narration about his identity.
  • Another winner short, keeping up this era’s (and season) winning streak alive. I so appreciate this short going melancholic, reflective instead of relying on man-on-man kissing as its laugh-getter. A new favorite of mine.

Rating: *****

Musical Performance – “Bobby”

Weekend Update

TOB sings about Thanksgiving with family

  • We are starting off hot from the get-go with the Huang and FAA topics as our headlines.
  • While yet another ferry mention, it was a decent joke in reaction to the FAA mess.
  • Nice seeing a mention of Airplane! which is my personal favorite comedy film of all-time.
  • Eh at that pimp joke. Michael seems to be getting some groaners of late, such as that lame Mike Johnson one last week.
  • A solid midlife crisis joke from Colin, though we really did not need Michael to ad-lib there.
  • This Dementia or Lying, which gave me a good laugh, feels similar to the bits Tina Fey and Jimmy Fallon would do in their tenures.
  • Not going to bitch yet again over the audience screaming over the punchline of Michael’s Communist regime joke. They clearly did not get it.
  • Sweet to see Tommy doing an Update song, complete with playing the keyboard. I know he auditioned to SNL with a song and he sings a lot during his stand-up shows.
  • Tommy is coming off endearing as always, and while I really like Jane and grown to appreciate her talents, I feel her musical abilities shine more in pretapes, such as Cousin Planet. Perhaps Tommy being a better live performer, or him singing more about relatable topics, but I am enjoying this and it feels nice instead of having a mascot on there.
  • With that said, I still would love having a duet on Update. This cast has so many great singers and it would be fun to see them paired more in a live format.
  • I can tell Tommy is a bit nervous, which is odd to me, as he’s been a solid, dependable cast member (and this is a strong cast in general), but it is still endearing.
  • The “you can still be mean if you are gay” lyric was my biggest laugh here.
  • I am surprised Update is ending this early, but I guess I cannot really complain. A decent desk piece (I am still waiting for standouts since the third episode of the season, however), some solid jokes and the pacing went by quick.

Rating: ***1/2

Central Park Horse & Carriage Ride

Central Park visit sparks musical

  • I had hoped we moved on from these musicals, even when I was never as down on them as a number of fans seem to be. I was let down by the dull one in John’s prior episode. As for the 50th one, I have zero memories of it somehow, which is very odd.
  • Surprised we never did Central Park in one of these. These specific references give me nice memories as a former New Yorker.
  • Veronika getting a solo number feels about right, as she is one of the three best singers in this cast, alongside Tommy and JAJ.
  • Veronika is absolutely fantastic in this! Totally killed this number. Moments like these makes me bewildered how underused this brilliant performer has been so far this season.
  • Even John’s scripted line in reaction to Veronika’s number was true and funny.
  • Another nice pairing of Tommy and John. Telling you all, they both could be relatives.
  • This is a lot more fun and energetic than the one from John’s prior hosting stint. Maybe because this cast is, in my view, near the top in the show’s history in musical abilities.
  • WTF at the Mikey moment?
  • Ben was very fun in the brief cutaway to him.
  • JAJ’s vocal range continues to amaze me. Can we get him, Veronika and Tommy on Broadway, please?
  • I love the duo between Jeremy and JAJ. Them falling in love at the end gave me a little smile.
  • Bowen feels even more like a cast member instead of a former alum as he now gets his own fun little number.
  • Nice and rare callback with Ashley’s Kathy showing up in another sketch. A bit odd she did not sing, but I love the very rare times in modern SNL where we get runners like this.
  • I found this in general to be really fun, in spite of the length. A big upgrade from the prior two, off the top of my head.

Rating: ***1/2

Woodstock

baby boomer hippies plan their future

  • Mikey Day is a natural as a high hippie.
  • John looks hilarious in that wig and outfit combo.
  • I am not sure what to think of this sketch in general. It’s been decent so far and the cast are fine playing 1960s hippies. Nothing really has been hitting me, outside of John’s amusing delivery.
  • The Baby Boomers being greedy and selfish is a good callback to the monologue earlier tonight.
  • A bit of an odd ending, if you can call it that. But, John made it work with his reliable delivery.

Rating: ***

Musical Performance – “Still Standing”

Cut For Time: Bob Dylan & The Pope

Pope Leo (host) meets Bob Dylan (JAJ)

  • This clearly was apparently going to air, judging by the endless bumpers of John and then the band shot, before we went to commercial. I am surprised it was a full sketch instead of a desk piece, but I guess it works either way.
  • Such a dead-on Bob Dylan impression from JAJ, especially I am loving all those weird references he adds in to the impression (which is something he also does with his also-dead-on Trump), as I am familiar with Dylan’s radio show as a massive fan of his (especially the mid 1960s run and late ’90s/early 00s runs).
  • The whole talk about chastity is cracking me the hell up, especially JAJ’s great Dylan voice delivering all these lines. I also loved his Alzheimer’s line.
  • Very funny seeing John struggling to keep a straight face after the funny “son of a sausage maker” line from JAJ’s Dylan.
  • Fun, silly stuff, probably a little niche to those not as well-versed in Dylan as yours truly (and clearly JAJ), but this would have been a fun end to the night.

Rating: ***1/2

Cut For Time: Svetlana and Kurt

couple (BEM) & (SAS) tell each other everything

  • James: Interesting pairing of Ben and Sarah. Also, not to be that guy, but Sarah looks fantastic here
  • Decent concept parodying the whole Jensen Huang news story, even when I feel the cold open said all that really needed to be said on it.
  • I’m liking Ben’s cheesy nerdy persona here.
  • Mixed thoughts on the breaking here. Sometimes it can enhance or even make a sketch in the case of the first Debbie Downer or the classic Succinctly Speaking sketch. Hell, Sarah herself made it charming and fun in the Murder Detective sketch from the S49 Ramy Youssef episode. But other times it devolves into self-indulgent jackassery (see Jimmy Fallon and Horatio Sanz). I’m somewhere in between at the moment. This is feeling far too loose. Then again, it’s dress rehearsal I suppose.
  • Really didn’t need Colin to point out Sarah’s breaking as it both made it worse (not to mention made Ben and Colin himself crack up) and is making this piece drag out longer.
  • The turns with Sarah beating Ben up are decent enough for a quick laugh, though I kind of wish they escalated it more.
  • I’m not caring at all for Colin’s involvement here, especially the “shocking” insult towards Sarah which results in endless braying, mugging and “horrified” reactions from everyone (including Sarah fucking hiding behind the Update desk). The show has gone to this well of “Colin being sexist/racist” SO many times that it’s become so predictable and has lost whatever shock value it once had. This isn’t the daring edgy stuff the show and its performers think it still is.
  • A slight chuckle from the sniper lasers aimed at Ben when he questions her intentions.
  • Yeah, I can see why this was cut. It was way longer than it needed to be (sadly a recurring theme for Sarah’s Update pieces) and the loose sloppy performances from all involved really dragged it down.

Rating: **

Cut For Time: Hiram Jones

Mississippi’s first black senator (KAP) on Scott Colom’s win

  • James: Two CFT desk pieces in a row! Let’s hope this one is better than that overlong Sarah/Ben one.
  • I’m really torn when it comes to Kam Patterson. He comes off decent and likable on the show (much more so than I would have thought given his Kill Tony background), but his range is also severely limited and he always seems to just be playing himself. Sometimes this can work, and I can maybe see Lorne perceiving Kam as a Tracy Morgan type cast member, but I’m not sure it’s been working as well as he wants. Anyways, on to this piece…
  • The concept of no one having heard of Hiram Revels nor celebrating his historic achievement is decent if rather predictable.
  • Did we really need another fourth wall break acknowledging that Kam knows nothing about the figure he’s portraying? Self-deprecation is fine once in a while, but this feels a bit desperate on the part of both Kam and the show to point out his lack of range and knowledge.
  • The whole “gay” turn here is not working for me. I may feel differently about that if this were a different performer, but knowing how Kam (and his Kill Tony cohorts) sometimes relies on hacky gay jokes in his standup, this vaguely has an air of punching down to it. Maybe I’m overthinking it.
  • Kam’s outrage at the Democrats was pretty solid
  • The faux dramatic portion with Kam’s Hiram inadvertently saying a bunch of right wing/MAGA-coded phrases is good enough for a quick laugh, even if Kam’s Kill Tony background gives it a bit of unfortunate subtext.
  • Overall this piece came and went for me. A couple of laughs here and there, but nothing too memorable. Again, I can see why this was cut.

Rating: **1/2

Goodnights

Segments Ranked From Best to Worst

Sister: Elder Care System

Gettin’ It Done

Monologue

CIA Meeting

CFT: Bob Dylan & The Pope

Weekend Update

Central Park Horse & Carriage Ride

Woodstock

Coworkers Drinks

Plane Crash

Final Thoughts:

  • A strong episode, particularly the first half, which was amazing. All that worked for me in said half getting a rating between 4-5 stars. Very impressive. The episode did cool down as we reached Update (which was still solid), but the whole show is still a lot of fun, in spite of the minimal amount of segments compared to the usual SNL episode. John Mulaney was fun, solid and laid-back as usual and while he did not take over the show, he gave it a comforting feeling and delivered a strong set and worked well with the cast.
  • This episode seemed to have quite an odd pacing, with us not only getting just two sketches post-Update, but the first half only having six comedic segments. Clearly, a sketch had to be cut at the last minutes after the second musical performance, given away by the endless amount of host bumpers (though they were nice to look at). This season seems to struggle with how its timed, as this is the second time in three episodes we had this issue, after the Inde Navarrette episode just two weeks ago.

My Favorite Moments of the Episode, Represented with Screencaps:

My full set of screencaps from this episode is here

14 Replies to “November 14, 2026 – John Mulaney / Phoebe Bridgers (S52 E6)”

  1. Honestly, it would be more surprising if a John Mulaney episode didn’t bring the goods at this point. Though admittedly, I was a little worried that if we made it past this episode without it being good, this season would be in deep trouble. Glad they can still bring the goods like this when the situation allows.

    Glad to see the show pivot away from the Trump cabinet parodies that were admittedly getting a little repetitive this season. I would definitely be down to see more political, yet not presidential cold opens mixed in soon. It was a great chance to see some cast members you don’t normally see in cold opens, like Andrew, Ben, and Jane, plus I did enjoy all the back and forth with John’s character. Bowen, I thought was maybe back a little soon, but at the same time, it’s not like the show actually has any Asian cast members to fill in Huang’s shoes. They should probably rectify that soon, to be honest.

    The monologue was far and away the best they’ve done this season, though the competition hasn’t exactly been stellar. It honestly makes me think of Shane’s monologue as being worse in hindsight – the standup here just feels so much sharper and tightly written, even if it was reused from the material he’s previously done.

    I think what I really enjoyed about this episode is that they pulled back on recurring bits for the most part, and the ones they did pick felt a bit fresher than they usually do. I think my main grievance with the last ones were all the live sketches being ones they did before, and to see ones bookending the show was good.

    Sketch of the night was probably that Gettin’ It Done bit with Jeremy. I was really worried with the man-on-man kiss that they would just ride it for laughs like the Heated Wizardry sketch last year, but I’m glad they went in a more character-driven direction. The editing, camerawork, and narration were all top-notch, and it gave me a little bit of Stefon energy if that makes sense (which I guess make sense given the episode).

    Most of the other pieces tonight were pretty good, with no obvious stinker like last episode. If I were to single one out as being weaker, it’d probably be that Woodstock sketch. I get what they’re going for with the material (a sort of spiritual continuation of Washington’s Dream), but it felt a bit too on-the-nose for me to really laugh at here, plus the live-action cutaways were a little distracting. Maybe it’s the boomer stuff in the monologue messing with my perception, but at least it wasn’t outright bad.

    The recurring bits this time were thankfully better than they usually are. The Cathy sketch legitimately scared me with that first “we talkin” but I think the material here was pretty decent, even if it did start to get retread-y towards the end. As a character, Cathy is far from the most annoying or slavishly repetitive we’ve had on the show, which is usually the sign of a bad recurring sketch. The musical sketch was likewise decent. Glad we got to see something with Veronika’s musical ability, since it’s been a minute since she’s been given a ton to do. Tommy’s bit was probably my favorite, though, glad they gave something in service of how similar he looks to John in this episode.

    Update, I have mixed feelings about. While I did like a fair few jokes this time, I couldn’t help but think Colin and Michael seemed stumbly and unfocused with their delivery. That overlong pause and ad-lib before the Russell Brand joke was probably the biggest example. I thought the delivery was definitely better the previous two episodes this season, so it seems a bit sad to see them take a step back in this one. Maybe it really is time for new anchors. Tommy’s piece was actually pretty good, but it felt so weird to me. Apparently this was pretty par for the course with his comedic stylings (like you mentioned he auditioned with a song, and other people have said it’s similar to what he usually does stand-up with), but it felt eerily similar to Jane’s songs in my view, even down to the delivery. I kept expecting her to show up midway through to tell him off for this. Hey, if it gets Tommy screentime, it shouldn’t be a problem, and I’m hoping this gives him some necessary momentum throughout this season after the abysmal first few episodes he had.

    Overall, I can’t really complain about this episode’s quality at all. Very much the most solid of this season so far, and it’s nice to be rebounding like this. Hopefully Amanda Seyfried brings some of the goods with her episode, though I admittedly think the show is cashing in on the You Can See Everything buzz a tad late. Great review!

  2. I tend to agree, this is probably the best episode in this season so far, and not a single sketch bottomed out for me, so I think we’re in a good place now for this season, and it can go only uphill from here.
    BTW, they posted this Cut for Time Update piece with Ben and Sarah, and tons of breaking: https://youtu.be/k-4sSm-OFYw?si=B95vop4BPgig2qf6

  3. My favorite episode of this season including my favorite Cold Open (A VERY low bar) and Monologue (Not a major challenge). Could’ve gone without the Kathy appearances and wasn’t a fan of the Pretapes but I’ll take the good where I can.

  4. Great review once again, Blood.

    I thought this episode was alright. Not bad, but I guess it kinda lacked the “special” feeling a good majority of Mulaney’s episodes have (His first two, S47). I do have a feeling that I’ll feel higher on this episode if I give it a rewatch later on in the season.

    The Sister pretape was my favorite segment, just great performances (Jane continuing her strong start to this season), a great concept, and great writing.

    I also really liked Update this time around. The jokes were mostly good and I honestly loved Tommy’s commentary. It had such an infectious energy and by the end of it, I had “Happy Turkey Day” stuck in my head (and it’s still stuck). I would LOVE to see both Jane and Tommy do a song together on Update, but it’s probably never gonna happen. Also, the Bo Burnham fan in me wonders if Bo was in the audience, and how he felt about Tommy’s song.

    I also really liked the Cold Open. It felt SO nice to finally see something different, and the writing was surprisingly strong here. Mulaney was also a fantastic anchor for it.

    My main issues with the episode were Kathy 2 and the 7th Mulaney Musical. I felt kinda mixed about the first Kathy sketch (“We talkin’ TV?”was numbing my brain near the end of that), and this just did NOT need a sequel. I felt nothing watching the whole thing. Also, it felt like Ashley was just going a bit too broad this time around. Kathy’s random appearance in the Musical was great though. The character should stick to quick appearances like that.

    The Mulaney Musicals feel so phoned in at this point. The 50th Anniversary installment should’ve ended this staple.

    Also I unfortunately couldn’t really get down with Mulaney’s monologue this time around. The first half was great, and him talking about his Autistic Dad might be one of my favorite bits he’s done in all of his SNL monologues. But the whole RFK section REALLY brought this whole thing down for me. It just goes on for wayyyyyyyy too long, and the whole bit just feels so off-putting to me. Also, this might be just me, but did anyone else think Mulaney seemed to have a different vibe here? Post-Rehab Mulaney has had a more less “cartoon-y” persona when he’s doing stand-up, but for some reason, it seemed like he was trying to get back into that style here. Also, he was going VERY fast for this whole thing. I’m probably overthinking though.

    This is probably second to last if I were to rank his monologues, with his October 2020 monologue being at the bottom.

    Everything else in the episode was just okay to me. Nothing bad, and the energy was in the right place, but not much was particularly strong.

    I’m not really familiar with Amanda Seyfried (though I really feel like I should be) but I’m looking forward to the show. I think this season has finally found its groove.

  5. (Blood, thanks for sharing so much about yourself in this review! )

    I loved this episode, for all the reasons you mentioned, and really am impressed with the musical talents of many of the cast members. Broadway-worthy, and we all know our beloved Bowen is already killing there.

  6. By default, this was probably the best episode of the season, and a nice improvement from Mulaney’s previous hosting stint.

    This season continues to knock it out of the park with the pretapes. It’s too early to say for sure, but this era could end up rivalling the 2010s era in terms of stellar pretapes. The Sister pretape is a strong contender for the best sketch of the season so far. Profoundly relatable, hilarious, and even sweet.

    Ditto for Gettin’ It Done, which I’m glad didn’t make the whole “man-on-man” kiss thing the butt of jokes. Instead it took its time, had some wonderful dramatic acting from Jeremy and John, and had a nice progression and escalation to it that made the whole thing come off sincere and not cheap.

    I’m thrilled the cold open tonight was not another Trump one, especially another “freezing”. This was an excellent way of addressing the Jensen Huang story, and the performers (especially JAJ) were hilarious. This is exactly the kind of refreshing and writerly concepts the show should be moving towards more often for these cold opens as we transition into the lame duck phase of Trump’s presidency.

    As much as I rolled my eyes at yet another Mulaney musical (seriously, when will he/the show learn they will NEVER top Diner Lobster?), I have to admit this one was an improvement over the one in Mulaney’s previous episode. It helps, as you said, that this cast is so musically talented and they brought nice theater kid energy (the good kind, not the obnoxious kind) to this piece.

    Meh on the Kathy retread, but I can think of worse instances of the show forcing recurring characters/sketches. At least the callback at the end of the musical sketch was fun and unexpected. I’m always a sucker for continuing characters/concepts in unrelated sketches.

    I was spoiled Bowen’s cameo prior to the episode and felt it was a little too soon, but he was fun and likable in both of his appearances tonight. I can’t say that I miss him as a cast member, but it was a nice reminder of the fun energy he brought to the show at his best.

    Psyched for Amanda Seyfried hosting! I have no doubt she’ll do a great job. Especially thrilled to see someone new, not to mention a “why haven’t they hosted already?” type host!

  7. This is probably controversial, but I wasn’t a big fan of the episode. Sure, there were some bright spots like Tommy’s Update song, the Sister commercial, and I liked most of that Brewery thing except for the gay kissing, but a lot of it felt bland or rehashed from previous episodes.

    Case in point: the musical sketch, which I think has long outstayed its welcome. The one at the 50th Anniversary special looked like they were finally putting a stop to them, given that Kenan showed up as the lobster at the end. But nope! We gotta keep doing them cuz the Mulaney simps expect it!

    Also, the Bowen cameos were unnecessary and unfunnya. Couldn’t he have waited more than one season to make his return to the show?

    1. I mean, the cameos make sense. The needed an Asian if they wanted to portray Jensen, and bringing in a current Broadway star as their character for the Musical Sketch felt right. At least it wasn’t as quick as Fred Armisen’s first cameo after his departure

  8. I just saw a terrific sketch of John and JAJ playing the Pope and Dylan, with the latter’s recent visit widely covered in the media. How is it that some markets get cut off so much earlier than others? Or did this sketch not make it anywhere? Seemed pretty funny.

  9. Couldn’t wait to see your review of this episode Blood!

    Best episode! Had me laughing out loud often.

    I didn’t hate Cathy, Ashley’s pause timing was spot on…. And clearly they really strung out the “you talkin’ transpo?” only to set up the callback which almost knocked me out of my seat with laughter.

    It was only Woodstock that brought me down a bit, but the rest was really really good. You could tell John spent quite some time writing for this episode well before the week began.

    I just loved it, especially because SNL has been disappointing for many months overall to me. And even better? Mikey and Keenan didn’t bother me one bit!

    I was hoping Trump would step into the Cold Open but no one would freeze and Abdul El-Sayed and Mandani would walk in to pull Trump out of there, with a huge blue safari prop wave chasing them off.

    Thank yew as usual Blood! Great work by you!

  10. If had to rank Mulaney’s previous episodes from best to worst, I’d say his 2nd time was the best, his 5th time being a close second, than 1st, 3rd, 6th, and 4th. I’d say this one is slightly better than his first episode which was a pretty solid outing.

  11. A lot of thoughts here really reflect my own, so I will try not to blab too long. It was a good episode – arguably the season’s best. But something still seems to be missing…

    • THIS is what we need from cold opens. A new angle, a fresh story, new impressions, a motherfucking PREMISE!!! Hell, it doesn’t even have to be hi-larious, as this one wasn’t. Just write a functional sketch and let it play out.
    • As much as I have come to loathe the musical pieces, energy and talent can get you a lot of places. This one was teeming with both – it earned its stripes. Bonus points for the Cathy callback.
    • Speaking of Cathy…you know what, this era has such a dearth of recurring characters (the show just re-hashes premises, which is less enjoyable to me) that I will fully, whole-heartedly embrace bringing this character back. It’s so thin, premise-wise, that I’m actually interested to see the character explored more. Do I LOVE these sketches? Not particularly, though I was an appreciator of the first, but I think we’re overdue for the show starting to really dig in with characters once again. Don’t reject the sameness, embrace the opportunity to dig deeper.
    • The Woodstock thing was once again the perfect kind of 10-to-one. Fun, but a little underbaked. That’s how I like ’em.
    • Great episode for Tommy, who I really believe has the goods to really deliver on the show.
    • While Tommy is starting to round into form, can we admit that Jane and Jeremy have completely arrived? JAJ and Ashley feel like the team captains (I don’t see the oldheads as even being on the team), but Jane and Jeremy feel like the MVPs so far.

    OK, those are the quick hits. I didn’t mention the pre-tapes, which were obviously the best of the night and featured brilliant, richly observed performances from Jane and Jeremy in their respective scenes. These are probably our best pre-tapes of the season, which is saying something. But that also kind of speaks to the central problem of the season. As good as any pre-tape can be, they no longer thrill me. I am most excited by the live element of the show. This week delivered a lot of good live material, but nothing particularly exceptional. This season, in six episodes, we’ve had maybe two exceptional live sketches (could have been three but one was CFT). That sort of leaves these episodes feeling kind of empty. Last season wasn’t exactly a hall of fame year (and the pre-tapes were merely okay), but the show was regularly delivering at least one great live piece a week. There was just a freshness to the live sketches last year (think about the range of White Castle Drive Thru, Mechanical Bull, Experienced Lawyers, Rasta Driver, Auctioneers – that’s all before we get to Ashley’s historic run of sketches). This season, with the exception of She Said Yes, has just lacked that sense of go-for-broke unpredictability and play.

    This was a Mulaney episode through and through, which means there was a lot of interesting material. Truly nothing bottomed out. But I still feel like the show is failing to deliver on its primary value proposition.

  12. Y’know, in taking a musical theater class, I thought for certain that I’d recognize more songs in our obligatory musical sketch, but I weirdly recognized less songs than usual.

Leave a Reply

Discover more from Blood’s SNL Reviews

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading